2008年9月2日 星期二

「科技發展局」不倫不類

IT戇豆說「IT應該做主角」,所以提出一個叫什麼「科技發展局」的物體出來。本來,提出這些口惠而實不至的政綱,怎樣講、叫什麼名稱也沒有所謂,因為沒有人會記得。只可惜戇豆的班底「唔夠pro」,講多錯多露了底,令人知道他根本連提政綱的能力也沒有,令人慨嘆那些支持他的人仍看不出他如此無能。到底他們給什麼蒙蔽了?

任何功能組別的候選人也可以提出成立「XX發展局」,去「支持業界發展」,空頭支票儘管開,完全沒有所謂。不過筆者說譚生露了底,因為他做了那麼多年生產力促進局副主席,連香港公共行政101這科也不合格。

戇豆提出的「科技發展局」,是以貿易發展局為藍本,負責「制訂和落實可持續發展的長遠科技政策...」

露底的就是這句。貿發局是什麼機構呢?話說六十年代,立法局的委任非官守議員大多是香港的商人,他們年復一年要求政府推廣香港的產品。雖然當時的財政司是支持自由市場的郭伯偉,也抵不住他們的壓力,於是成立了貿發局,但卻要收取出口稅支持貿發局。貿發局保的,只是「滋滋尾尾」的展覽會和旅行團,但香港的經濟政策,包括各行業的發展策略,仍然留在政府的政策局。

什麼叫「政策局」?殖民地時代負責制訂政策的全叫「司」,如教育司、經濟司(當然,筆者總覺得「司」比較好聽)。九七後,這些「司」全改為「局」,今天的什麼「教育局」...全都是制訂政策的部門。政策局只負責制訂政策,所以往往只有很少職員,執行政策的工作多交由「署/處」去做。無論是局還是署/處,過去所有職員都是公務員,現在則只有局長、副局長和政治助理為非公務員。簡而言之,負責制訂政策的,必為政府。

至於貿易發展局、旅遊發展局、生產力促進局等只不過是「法定機構」,所有職員都不是公務員,如領了四百萬元的總幹事臧明華。這些法定機構的總幹事或行政總裁一般要聽命於一個董事局,而董事局的成員由政府委任,大多與該行業有關的商人名流。這些法定機構的職能要按法例而定,例如推廣旅遊和貿易等。

好了,到底戇豆想成立一個法定機構,還是一個政策局?如果是法定機構,我們接受由電盈、新世界、九倉、網上行、微軟、NEC......來制訂香港的科技政策嗎?我們想改變現在由公務員和問責局長制訂政策的制度嗎?如果資訊科技界如此做,香港要不要一個飲食發展局,由美心和大家樂來制訂香港的飲食政策?還有,我們要不要一個司法發展局、會計發展局......去滿足所有功能組別的議員?現在由公務員主理的政策局是否可以「摺埋」?

戇豆這個建議,可以說是一個「政治改革」,藍天蔚實在驚為天人,因為他解決了民主派經常批評的「官商勾結」:以後直接由商人治港,曾蔭權和俞宗怡真要錫佢一啖!如果實行這個戇豆建議,以後就不再有「梁展文事件」,因為日後新世界會負責香港的房屋和土地政策,那麼「梁展文」退休後加入新世界又有什麼問題呢?

本來,尋常伯姓提出這樣的建議是情有可原,因為市民毋須了解政府架構和運作,但一個「似樣」的立法會候選人,提出如此建議,只會顯示他無知。不錯,很多立法會議員都很「騎呢」,只是筆者不知道IT戇豆的志願是做一個如蕭敏華的騎呢的候選人而已。

36 則留言:

scleung 梁兆昌 提到...
作者已經移除這則留言。
scleung 梁兆昌 提到...

譚老闆何止 公共行政101 唔掂, 經濟101 都要肥佬!

譚老闆提出「XX發展局」概念前,有無計過條數,有無做過可行性研究?貿易發展局2007年的經費是20億港元,「XX發展局」的收入從何而來?

佢講過有幾個可能的來源,但都係計唔掂數喎:
(1) 財政盈餘 ---- 咁經濟不景時點算?
(2) 基金利息 ---- 究竟要在公帑撥多少成立基金,才可以提供每年20億元的利息?
(3) 數碼港和科學園的收入盈餘 ---- 有無搞錯?它們每年有20億元的盈餘嗎?係唔係要大幅加租呀?租戶和業界願意加租去資助這個「XX發展局」嗎?

我話,如果政府每年有20億多餘錢,不如直接投放在創新科技、研究及推廣科技,駛鬼養多班「XYZ局」的臧明華之流?

你譚老闆認真識攤大手向政府要錢 …… 有無 Cost Benefit Analysis去說服政府,說服其他議員? 醒少少,唔該! 拜託!

藍天蔚 提到...

梁兆昌:

我並非譚偉豪,攪清楚。

藍天蔚

匿名 提到...

莫乃光被投訴作虛假聲明

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

【新報訊】有市民昨日去信選管會,質疑資訊科技界別候選人莫乃光2004年辭去香港互聯網註冊管理公司(HKIRC)董事一事,在立法會競選期間多次作虛假聲明,隱瞞事實,指當年是基於對HKIRC管治意見不同才離開,據投訴人了解,當年HKIRC董事局通過決議要求莫辭職。投訴人指莫隱瞞因涉及利益衝突被迫辭職的事實。不過,莫乃光昨晚回應查詢時強調所言屬實,沒誤導選民。

莫聲稱沒誤導選民

據了解,這名市民要求廉署介入調查事件。本報昨收到有關投訴信,內附當年HKIRC的法律意見文件副本、莫乃光在選舉論壇發言記錄、在網站上言論記錄等。

投訴信指,不滿莫乃光競選期間多次在選舉論壇及向傳媒發布虛假聲明,或誤導性陳述。投訴信指莫也在其網誌上聲稱「部分董事對此事理念不同,共五名董事在2004年5、6月相繼辭職,選擇在HKIRC架構以外繼續監察」,又稱「事件四年多前圓滿解決,從沒涉及任何法律程序,亦無利益衝突」。投訴人指莫的言論誤導選民,對另一候選人譚偉豪造成不公平。

「HKIRC事件」緣於莫乃光2004年曾一起擔任HKIRC董事及向HKIRC申請域名.asia義務顧問,莫後來辭職,並強調兩份工作都是義務性質,從沒取得任何域名生意業務或利益。不過,早前有人發放暗示是HKIRC法律顧問文件給傳媒,認為莫可能存在利益衝突。莫昨日表示,要解釋的已說過,強調HKIRC董事會當時沒任何決定,要進入程序或行動,跟進他被指涉及有利益衝突的事情。

匿名 提到...

莫乃光遭投訴發表誤導聲明

立法會資訊科技界選舉再起風雲,有人向選舉管理委員會投訴,不滿其中一名候選人莫乃光,指他至今仍公開聲稱在○四年辭任香港互聯網註冊公司(HKIRC)董事,是出於意見不合,而非涉及利益衝突,涉嫌發表誤導聲明。據了解,選管會已受理投訴。

莫乃光年前曾任「.hk」香港域名最高管理機構,即HKIRC的董事,早前多次遭對手譚偉豪及其他業界人士翻舊帳,指他當時同時出任「.asia」域名管理機構的顧問,有利益衝突之嫌而被HKIRC要求辭職,當中更可能涉及刑事成份,並以事件中的部份法律文件作證。

莫乃光其後回應,離職時曾與HKIRC協議不公開事件來龍去脈,要求HKIRC主席就今次洩密事件徹查及道歉,並一直公開重申當年離職不涉利益衝突。
頭條日報

匿名 提到...

A complaint on a false statement made by Mr Bean has been lodged with the Electoral Affairs Commission.

Please read newspaper in this week.

匿名 提到...

From the news in 新報 & 頭條日報, it is obvious that certain publishers are supporting Mr Bean in this election.

Should the cost be counted towards his election expenses??

cc 提到...

Frankly, I think you are not being fair to Mr Tam.

I don't understand why you keep on slamming him regardless of what he has done.

He is just a candidate and people being doubtful about you being the supporter of Mr Mok is justified.

It is too much.

From the time you have used the term "Bean" for him, you are not rational.

(personal view)

藍天蔚 提到...

cc,

I have stances on many things. You can also say that I am not fair to the editor of Ming Pao since I didn't criticize the language used in editorials of Apple Daily.

However, pls be reminded that I am writing a blog expressing MY views. I think Samson Tam is an idiot and I write it. I need not to be "fair" even if I am operating a newspaper, it's not justified to request a blogger to be "fair", if you understand the underlying meaning of a "blog". In case you don't, pls visit Wiki for some background information. http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLOG

Lam Tin Wai

藍天蔚 提到...

譚偉豪及莫乃光助選團:

歡迎繼續在此對打,我不再逐個回應你們了。

藍天蔚

匿名 提到...

I enjoy watching the fencing games played by the two teams!

Please keep on!

;-)

匿名 提到...

Fencing is a gentleman's sport. To describe such kind of street fights as fencing is an insult to the sport and fencers ar...

Am also curious watching how far could these guys go.

You're right to keep your stance and spare your time. Can't talk to 'mind blind' people really.

Allez!

c'est moi

匿名 提到...

Unlike the normal fencing, the two players are pointing at the back of their opponent!

Whether you accept or not, such dirty jobs are usually done by supporters of the candidates in each election all over the world except those autocratic countries where voice of objection cannot be expressed openly.

This is politics!

匿名 提到...

IT practitioners may find it hard to understand why they don't know the names of a number of supporters of Dr Tam, like A*T, C*F, C*P, K*H, K*F, K*H, L*H, L*S, L*H, L*Y, L*Y, L*S, P*T, *K, T*K, V*V, W*P, *K, as published in his website.

Though these persons are not working in the IT industry, they have voting rights in IT FC.

This reflect the seriousness of seeded votes in IT FC.

匿名 提到...

莫乃光辭職事件 何沛德被控泄密
(明報)9月4日 星期四 12:00

【明報專訊】資訊科技界候選人莫乃光早前在有線電視 的選舉論壇中,被指於2004年因利益衝突而辭去互聯網註冊管理有限公司(HKIRC)董事一職,當日「踢爆」事件的HKIRC前董事何沛德,被指違反保密協議,日前遭HKIRC入稟高院禁制止他再發表有關言論,並要求何沛德交代消息來源及賠償損失。

原訴人為HKIRC,被告何沛德為該公司04至07年的董事。入稟狀指出,原訴人要求禁制何作出任何違反04年9月27日簽訂的保密協議的行為,即禁止他公開有關公司和公司僱員的資料和消息。

莫乃光04年曾因同時擔任HKIRC董事及「.asia」顧問,被質疑有利益衝突而辭職,早前在選舉論壇中,何沛德要求莫解釋事件,莫認為何的提問違反保密協議,去信HKIRC要求處理。HKIRC早前曾書面要求何登報向公司及莫道歉,但何反指他非因公司文件得悉事件,只是從其他途徑知悉,事件中他並無任何責任。資訊科技界選舉中另一候選人為譚偉豪。

【入稟編號:HCA1641/08】

匿名 提到...

Mr Bean has crazily sent large number of junk mails to members of professional institutions today! However, the number of copies of each election ad was not shown. These advertisements might not have been filed with EAC.

A complaint will be lodged with EAC tomorrow.

藍天蔚 提到...

匿名:

要問的問題是:為什麼戇豆有那些人的電郵。

藍天蔚

匿名 提到...

Good question!

Mr Bean had been members of a number of IT institutions. The e-mail addresses might be obtained from these institutions like HKIE IT Division. As the personal data are collected by professional institutions for membership service, such misuse of personal data might have violated the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance.

Maybe a complaint should be filed with Mr WOO Bun, Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data.

If the IT institutions were not aware of such misue of personal data, this incident should be reported to the Police!

blog marketing 提到...

飞龙搬家公司,是一家专业性北京搬家公司,企业诚信,员工搬运专业,是北京搬家公司行业的后起新秀,公司长期为搬家免费纸箱。欢迎重询!
公兴上海搬场公司是经工商,税务,交通部注册的一家专业性的上海搬家公司,诚实信誉,工作细心,服务热情;为上海搬场,上海搬家的企业,如有需求,敬请垂询本搬场公司
海胜数码快印有限公司,致力于数码印刷,诚实信誉,实力雄厚,技术专业,设备先进,设计新颖,是北京数码印刷行业中新秀一支,愿做北京数码快印需求者的忠诚合作伙伴!
佳佳乐月嫂服务中心,精心提供月嫂服务,育儿嫂服务,育婴师服务,本中心月嫂,育儿嫂,育婴师,均通过健康体验,经过严格培训,持
证上岗.
华夏国际机票预定中心,全程代销各航机票
,特价机票,北京特价国际机票,留学生机票,打折机票,打折的价格,增值的服务
, 国际机票预订中心精心哈护你的远航!
星云科技,诚信于教育;研究出电子起电机,语音室,语言实验
,数字探究实验室,数字化实验室,探究实验室,系列探究实验配套设施,望广大院校前来考察!
北凝科技,废汽,余热回收,热力除氧改造,凝结水
治理专家,其推出的,定连排,烟囱余热回收器,乏汽回收,低位热力除氧器,凝结水回收器,冷凝水,
等系列产品.
北京防水堵漏公司、专业承接防水
防水堵漏地下室防水地下室堵漏北京防水北京防水堵漏北京防水公司北京防水网.防水堵漏专家! 工作心细,滴水不漏!
 北京爱福石材养护有限公司是专业从事石材翻新,石材结晶,石材护理,石材清洗,石材养护的企业,专业提供:石材翻新,石材结晶,石材清洗,石材护理,石材养护,石材无缝处理,石材防护,石材防滑,石材病症预防处理,石材修补,石材日常保养等业务.服务专线010-82922015

匿名 提到...

It is actually a hefty unit, weighing about 300 pounds, that has
a solid three horsepower motor that delivers a good deal of electric power even for
uphill climbs.

Also visit my blog http://www.getfitnstrong.com

匿名 提到...

The only thing that you ought to keep in mind is that all heart amount screens make
use of the exact frequency (bluetooth) to speak in between the chest strap and wrist enjoy.


Take a look at my web-site http://www.getfitnstrong.com/bowflex-dumbbells/bowflex-adjustable-dumbbells/

匿名 提到...

Should you haven't put substantially assumed into it and just absent with whatever's all over, it could be value your time and energy to visit the music keep
and buy a few different types of picks.

Also visit my blog post ... http://www.getfitnstrong.com/bowflex-dumbbells/3-reasons-bowflex-selecttech-552-dumbbells/

匿名 提到...

Go on to elevate until they nearly touch your chin.



Look at my web page ... bowflex selecttech 552 dumbbells

匿名 提到...

This Bowflex Revolution XP assessment will aim for the functions this house health and fitness center provides.



Feel free to surf to my webpage; home Exercise Equipment

匿名 提到...

The main factor about physical fitness bands just like
the Bowflex electrical power rods is usually that immediately after
a while they'll shed their tensile power.

Feel free to visit my homepage; visit the up coming post

匿名 提到...

Now the moment you might have your adjustable dumbbells we could possibly get started.


Also visit my webpage ... lifecore dumbbells

匿名 提到...

The vital point to note about Alexander Zass was how he made his perception while
in the application of isometric work out.

Here is my web site :: http://www.getfitnstrong.com/adjustable-dumbbells/7-reasons-adjustable-dumbbell-set/

匿名 提到...

By far the most significant thing to contemplate is whether every one of the sections are present combined
with the over-all affliction from the tools in query.



Feel free to surf to my site - SITEMAP

匿名 提到...

This can conserve hundreds if not thousands of bucks, and
also the gains will be the similar.

Here is my site :: Personal Site

匿名 提到...

When people research the internet for the individual
products, the vast majority of them love to study the comments from others who definitely have bought
the product.

Also visit my webpage - hex dumbbells cheap

匿名 提到...

scar treatment Oak Brook

Also visit my web-site removing pimple scars photoshop

匿名 提到...

what doctor treats tennis elbow

My web blog ... tennis elbow symptoms and relief

匿名 提到...

Newport News laser treatment rosacea

My website - Vance Air Force Base rosacea specialist

匿名 提到...

These straps are placed with your leg, generally with velcro, plus the resistance band manage attaches for
the strap or the strap replaces the manage thoroughly.


Here is my homepage; free weight dumbells

匿名 提到...

Within this pursuit, some convert to household gear this kind of since the Bow Flex Tread climber.


Feel free to visit my page - weight dumbbell set

匿名 提到...

They will be made use of to do quite a few distinct arm workouts, chest exercise
routines, and shoulder strengthening exercises that make a person stronger and bulkier.



Also visit my website; adjustable dumbbells